Menu
Leah Pierson
  • Home
  • Blog
  • Podcast
  • CV
  • Home
  • Blog
  • Podcast
  • CV

Blog

Writing opinion pieces for medical journals as a medical student

7/31/2021

19 Comments

 
Haley Sullivan, Emma Pierson, Niko Adamstein, and Sam Doernberg gave helpful feedback on this post.

Many medical journals will publish ~1,000-word opinion pieces written by medical students. There is a lot of luck involved in getting these published, but here are tips others have given me, as well as lessons I have learned on how to do this:

  1. Presubmission inquiries are helpful. Many journals allow (or require) you to email them a short blurb about your piece before you formally submit it. It’s good to use this option when it’s available, especially if you haven’t written a draft yet. You’ll usually hear back quickly and may save yourself and the editors time (and the headache of formatting citations).
  2. Collaborate with people you like and respect. I have been assigned some amazing mentors and stumbled across some brilliant collaborators (it was helpful to be born into the same family as two of them). But I have also signed onto some projects with people I didn’t work well with, and none of these wound up getting published. For me, figuring out who to work with is mostly about compatibility, and this means identifying my own strengths and weaknesses (e.g., my writing is dry, so it’s good for me to work with people who have beautiful prose). Some ways I’ve tried to determine whether I’d work well with someone are: collaborating with them on a low-stakes/non-academic project, talking with other people they’ve worked with, meeting to assess vibes/communication style, reading other things they’ve written, and asking them for feedback on my writing. One litmus test is: if we got some reviews back on this piece, would I trust my co-author(s) to revise and resubmit this without my input? (I’m not saying I’d ever do this, but it’s good to know your collaborators well enough to make this assessment and to have this level of confidence in them.)   
  3. Be candid with people at the outset. During early brainstorming sessions about a piece, it’s useful to a) discuss how much time everyone can commit and over what time period b) outline the basic arguments for the piece (and make sure everyone roughly agrees) and c) clarify authorship order and roles. This is particularly important if you’re working with people you’re close to because you do not want to let work disputes harm your relationships. One litmus test for figuring out who should be first author is: who wrote the first draft of the piece? Having said this, sometimes circumstances change, and it becomes necessary to rethink authorship order. Authorship is definitely not worth burning relationships over. People are way more likely to work with you again if you were generous with them (about authorship, time, feedback, etc.) and if they're good collaborators, they will remember and pay it forward. Plus, it’s easy to overestimate how much work you have done.
  4. Get feedback on your ideas before you spend time writing them. These conversations can also be useful for figuring out how to frame an issue (e.g., what aspects of it are people interested in and what parts are they confused by?). Another way to get feedback on an idea is to tweet about it, although this presents some theoretical risk of getting scooped. On occasions I’ve done this, it’s helped me figure out whether people cared about an issue and agreed with the take.
  5. Get feedback before you submit your piece. This is pretty obvious. But one less obvious way it’s been useful: sometimes someone will tell you you’re aiming too low or too high. Last year, I sent a piece that wasn't very good to some friends, and one of them gently pointed out some major problems with it, and so I ended up turning it into a blog. On the other hand, I sent a blog post draft to a few friends who were like “you should publish this,” and after some serious revisions, I did.
  6. Shoot your shot. If people you respect have given you good feedback on an idea or a piece, it’s worth aiming high, especially with a presubmission inquiry. After all, there are a lot of journals and some of them publish a lot of short pieces.  
  7. Writing on time-sensitive issues is risky. I have had mixed success writing about things that are time-sensitive (petition to rename these pieces "deciduous"). On the one hand, lots of journals will want to publish a piece about a hot issue, and there are probably good, novel takes that haven’t been written yet. On the other hand, if you miss the window of opportunity, you may not be able to publish your piece at all. (RIP our article about whether medical students should be considered health care workers for the purposes of vaccine triage: it got reviewed, but by the time we got the R, most medical students had been vaccinated.) If you’re writing on a time-sensitive issue, submit a presubmission inquiry, consider sending the piece somewhere it won't be peer reviewed, and think about collaborating with someone who can help it move through review quickly. In other words…
  8. Consider finding someone senior to work with. I have only co-authored opinion pieces with friends/sisters. You may not need someone senior on your piece, especially if you’re writing about something you know a lot about (e.g., something specific to the medical student experience). I have never felt that my work wasn't taken seriously just because I was a medical student, and it can also be really fun to work with your friends. But having someone senior involved may often lead to a better product and increase your odds of getting it published. Senior people may have connections with editors and may be able to advocate for your piece more effectively.
  9. Have a backup plan. Have a short list of journals +/- a blog in mind before you start writing, and write with their word counts in mind. It is time-consuming to undertake major revisions (e.g., cut your piece in half) after each rejection.
  10. Write takes you’re excited about and think are true and important. I have only ever regretted getting pulled into projects I wasn’t excited about. Revising a piece for the 7th time is hard enough, even when you care about the issue. An added benefit is that even if you have a hard time getting your piece published, you’ll have read and thought a lot about an issue you care about.
Medical trainees will change the culture of medicine for the better (as generations of prior trainees have done for us), and we can accelerate this change by sharing our opinions. 
19 Comments
treatment facility for troubled youth link
4/8/2025 02:41:37 am

As a trusted treatment facility for troubled youth, we focus on emotional healing, behavior support, and personal growth. Our programs are designed to guide teens through challenges and prepare them for a brighter future.

Reply
how to format e-book for kindle publishing link
7/28/2025 06:56:39 am

Struggling with how to format my eBook for Kindle. Any tools or services you’d recommend that simplify the process?

Reply
Detox in Atlanta GA link
8/5/2025 03:44:25 am

Atlanta GA has some really reliable detox services, found the support I needed close to home.

Reply
mental health treatment program link
8/28/2025 01:00:27 am

Mental health treatment programs structured therapy sessions aur support services dete hain jo patients ko anxiety, depression, PTSD, aur other mental illnesses se cope karne mein madadgar hote hain.

Reply
Detox Atlanta link
8/29/2025 11:41:24 pm

Comprehensive detox programs in Atlanta helping individuals start recovery.

Reply
How Long Does Sublocade Stay In Your System? link
9/1/2025 05:01:26 am

I’ve been reading about medication-assisted treatments and was wondering—how long does Sublocade stay in your system? I’ve seen different answers online."

Reply
san luis obispo county drug and alcohol services link
9/2/2025 11:29:04 pm

This county-run service offers affordable drug and alcohol treatment, including walk-in clinics, outpatient programs, and special services for pregnant women and youth. They accept Medi-Cal and offer a sliding fee scale.

Reply
san luis obispo county drug and alcohol services link
9/3/2025 10:47:04 pm

It’s great that San Luis Obispo County has dedicated drug and alcohol services to support people in recovery. Not every county offers that.

Reply
rehab san luis obispo link
9/4/2025 01:10:22 am

Rehab centers in San Luis Obispo seem to combine professional treatment with a calming environment, which I think is so important for recovery.

Reply
detox centers nashville tn link
9/22/2025 11:00:10 pm

Detox centers in Nashville, TN deliver comprehensive services for individuals beginning their recovery journey. With medical supervision, tailored care, and a healing environment, these centers make detox safer and more effective.

Reply
inpatient mental health facilities in tennessee link
9/25/2025 02:13:40 am

Choose from leading inpatient mental health facilities in Tennessee with dedicated teams for crisis stabilization and long-term healing.

Reply
Alcohol Detox Atlanta link
9/26/2025 04:16:36 am

Alcohol detox in Atlanta provides safe medical supervision to help individuals withdraw from alcohol dependence, ensuring comfort and safety throughout the detox process.

Reply
drug rehab fremont ca link
10/13/2025 03:06:03 am

Drug rehab in Fremont, CA provides professional addiction treatment tailored to each individual’s needs. From detox to therapy and relapse prevention, local centers help clients overcome substance dependence and reclaim control of their lives in a safe, structured setting.

Reply
Dual Diagnosis link
10/15/2025 01:21:52 am

Dual Diagnosis refers to the co-occurrence of a mental health disorder and a substance use disorder. Treatment focuses on addressing both conditions simultaneously through integrated therapy, medication management, and relapse prevention strategies to achieve lasting recovery and stability.

Reply
treatment facility for troubled youth link
10/17/2025 05:46:40 am

A treatment facility for troubled youth offers structured, therapeutic programs that address behavioral issues, trauma, and mental health struggles in a safe, supportive environment.

Reply
Drug Detox Atlanta link
10/19/2025 10:59:49 pm

Drug Detox Atlanta provides personalized detox plans to manage withdrawal symptoms safely and comfortably for those overcoming substance dependence.

Reply
Detox Atlanta link
10/20/2025 10:52:54 pm

Detox Atlanta offers personalized detox programs to help people safely manage withdrawal and prepare for long-term recovery.

Reply
Drug Detox in Atlanta link
10/20/2025 11:23:47 pm

Drug Detox in Atlanta offers professional detox treatment to help individuals begin their journey to a substance-free life.

Reply
Atlanta Detox Center link
10/21/2025 12:39:21 am

Atlanta Detox Center provides comprehensive detox services, combining medical care and counseling to support lasting recovery.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Archives

    May 2025
    March 2025
    December 2023
    August 2023
    June 2023
    October 2022
    June 2022
    March 2022
    February 2022
    December 2021
    November 2021
    October 2021
    September 2021
    July 2021

    Categories

    All
    Bioethics
    Ethics Education
    Health Policy
    Medical Education
    Research Priority Setting

    Posts

    All
    Bioethics
    Ethics Education
    Health Policy
    Medical Education
    Research Priority Setting

    RSS Feed

Proudly powered by Weebly